Divided Argument

Divided Argument

An unscheduled, unpredictable Supreme Court podcast.

An unscheduled, unpredictable Supreme Court podcast. Hosted by Will Baude and Dan Epps. In partnership with SCOTUSblog.
Norway-Sweden Worshippers
Divided ArgumentJuly 13, 2026x
25
01:29:52205.68 MB

Norway-Sweden Worshippers

We cover two immigration wins in one day: the Court clears the way to end TPS for Haiti and Syria, then decides asylum turns on whether you "arrive in" the country — or merely at its border.

Smart Microwave
Divided ArgumentJuly 06, 2026x
24
01:25:13195.05 MB

Smart Microwave

We break down Chatrie v. United States, the Court's ruling that a geofence warrant is a Fourth Amendment search — what it does to the third-party doctrine and the mosaic theory, and where the separate opinions leave the law.

Weird Islands
Divided ArgumentJuly 02, 2026x
23
01:14:42170.99 MB

Weird Islands

The birthright-citizenship order goes down — but the vote is closer than anyone bet, and the four dissenters can't agree on why.

Always Already
Divided ArgumentJuly 01, 2026x
22
01:12:37166.19 MB

Always Already

Humphrey's Executor falls and independent agencies lose for-cause protection — but the Fed, alone, somehow survives.

Mechanical / Animal
Divided ArgumentJune 28, 2026x
21
00:56:10128.57 MB

Mechanical / Animal

We're in triage mode as the Court clears its end-of-term backlog. We run through the week's opinion dump before focusing on two cases that look unrelated but turn on the same question: when may a state rewrite background property law to limit a constitutional right? In Wolford v. Lopez , the Court s...